Comparing Above Ground vs. Underground Propane Tank Installation
Tank size is top of mind for a new propane system, but it’s only the first decision you’ll have to make. You’ll also need to select a place to put your tank and whether to position it above ground or below ground (buried).
Both above-ground and below ground options will safely store propane and allow for reliable fuel delivery. They’ll differ in things like total cost, appearance, installation requirements, and long-term maintenance. If you’re comparing above ground vs. underground propane tank installation, start with the pointers below to pick the best option for your property, budget, and fuel usage.
Above Ground Propane Tank Installation
Above ground tanks are the most common choice for residential homeowners. These tanks sit right on the surface of your yard, often with a concrete or gravel base (put in by the homeowner during installation). The install is faster and less disruptive because you don’t need to excavate, like you would for an underground tank.
There’s something to be said for the simplicity of this tank style. Above-ground systems are easier to install, easier to access for service, easier to inspect… Mainly you’re deciding that those things matter more than the clean aesthetics of a buried, hidden tank below the lawn..
| Advantages | Lower upfront installation costsFaster setup timelinesEasier maintenance and inspectionsSimpler tank replacement or service accessFlexible leasing options through many propane providers |
| Considerations | Even when placed carefully or screened with landscaping, the tank remains visible on the property.Local placement requirements and setback rules can also limit where it can be installed.Mowing, raking, and other yard upkeep has to work around the tank. |
It’s easiest (and most common) to lease above-ground systems rather than own them. Many homeowners like the ability to avoid the cost of an upfront tank purchase and instead work with a provider that installs and services the tank as part of the fuel relationship.
If you want to switch providers at any point, it’s also more straightforward to do so with a leased tank that’s above the ground. In many cases, tanks can simply be swapped out without excavation or major site work.
Final side note: From a visual standpoint, certain homeowners associations or property layouts may influence whether an above-ground tank is a practical choice.
Underground Propane Tank Installation
Underground propane tank installation places most of the tank below grade, with only the access dome left visible above the surface. Homeowners choose this option primarily for aesthetics. With the tank out of sight, it’s easier to achieve landscaping goals and preserve curb appeal or uninterrupted views of the surrounding scenery.
The underground approach is more popular for larger custom homes with open landscapes, but any properties where the homeowner wants outdoor living areas to remain visually uncluttered can benefit.
| Advantages | Cleaner appearance from the curb, minimal visible equipmentYardwork will be easier around the dome than a whole tankBetter preserves decorative landscaping and sightlinesLow visual impact on patios and outdoor living spacesProtection from weather exposure above ground |
| Considerations | The installation process is more involvedExcavation is required (greater labor/equipment needs, higher total installation cost)Site conditions must be appropriate for excavationMost propane companies require a tank purchase (rather than lease) due to the involved installation processAdditional steps for maintenance and inspections vs. an above-ground system |
For homeowners who are heavily invested in outdoor living spaces, underground tanks often align better with the overall design of the property. However, there could be challenges like rocky soil or drainage concerns that complicate the project and necessitate an above ground propane tank installation.
Tank ownership can be a consideration here as well. Since underground installations involve more permanent site work, most companies don’t provide underground tank leasing options. Homeowners must think carefully about their long-term plans and whether it makes sense to purchase the tank outright.
So, Which Option Is Better For My Home?
Well, what matters most for your property?
An above ground propane tank installation often works well for families who would prefer lower upfront costs and easier service access. An underground propane tank installation appeals more to long-term homeowners that prioritize aesthetics around the home.
A larger home with high propane demand might find it easier to justify the more permanent style of an underground system. Many moderate-use households, by comparison, prefer the simplicity of an above ground system.
Talk Through Your Property With a Local Expert
Every property has its own layout to consider, and each homeowner has unique fuel needs and long-term plans. Work through all of your questions around tank size, delivery access, landscaping, local codes, and household fuel demand with a propane expert before you make the final call.
Bumgarner Oil & Propane helps our neighbors evaluate those details every day in local Western Carolina communities. Get in touch with our team to chat about installation, leasing, and everything in between. We’re happy to help you decide what makes the most sense for your home.
